SEHN

Visionary Science, Ethics, Law and Action in the Public Interest

Geonotic Diseases: a New Taxonomy

Carolyn Raffensperger

By Carolyn Raffensperger

Premises:

1. There are taxonomies of human health and disease. Taxonomies are conceptual frameworks that organize our thinking by grouping things that share characteristics. One taxonomy of disease is based on the system of the body that is diseased: the endocrine system, the cardiovascular system, the nervous system. Within those systems there can be various disorders such as birth defects, cancer, or poisoning. Another taxonomy is the kind of disease: infectious disease, injuries, or chronic disease, as examples. Within the category of those diseases there can be further subdivisions. Within the domain of infectious diseases there are those known as zoonotic diseases. These are diseases that cross between species and are often carried by a vector such as mosquitoes or ticks.

2. Epidemiology specializes in two kinds of disease,  infectious and chronic. Frequently epidemiologists studying infectious disease investigate causes because there is usually a direct cause and a single effect with infectious diseases. Chronic disease specialists often study effects because many chronic diseases have multi-factorial causes making it harder to study causes.

3. Since the rise of industrialization the disease pattern has changed from primarily infectious disease to primarily chronic disease. Small pox and polio have been replaced by cardiovascular disease, diabetes and asthma.

4. When it focuses on effects, rather than causes of chronic disease, the medical professions emphasize treatment of disease, rather than prevention of disease.

5. The causes of chronic diseases are often complex, ecological (both biological and geological) and result from cumulative impacts of multiple stressors.

6. Within the category of chronic disease there is a subset of diseases that are Geonotic. That is, they are geologic, mineral or chemical in nature. These diseases result from disruptions or alterations in the geosphere. The vector or cause of the diseases are not living organisms, but geochemical materials.

7. Some Geonotic diseases can be passed from the Earth to humans and from humans to the Earth.  This is a feedback loop between the geochemical cycles of the Earth and living systems.

8. Kinds of Geonotic disease causes

  • A. concentrating geologic materials such as carbon or nitrogen–aerosol loading and air pollution, nitrogen loading and water pollution
  • B. creating and using toxic chemicals such as DDT
  • C. altering geochemical cycles such as nitrogen, calcium, phosphorus in the body and on the Earth
  • D. depleting certain materials such as phosphorus
  • E. dispersing some materials such as mercury

9. Examples of kinds of Geonotic diseases

  • A. Lead, Mercury and Arsenic poisoning
  • B. Asthma
  • C. Many cancer
  • D.Blue baby syndrome.
  • E. Asbestosis
  • F. Black Lung Disease
  • G. Phosphorus deficiency

10. Almost all of the Geonotic diseases can be attributed to violating ecological systems conditions as expressed in frameworks like the Natural Step.

11. Every geospherical system has been affected by human disruption: air, water, soil, fire, the deep Earth.

12. Scale matters with Geonotic diseases. Large scale mining such as mountain top removal or fracking, or oil drilling in the gulf, industrialized agriculture that concentrates and disrupts materials like nitrogen and selenium all have serious geologic consequences that are direct causes of human health disease. The garbage patch and the massive quantities of plastic (a geologic material) in the ocean, in addition to the acidification of the ocean changes the ecology of the ocean in ways that affect human health. Similarly small, micro changes in the human body of iron, calcium, phosphorus or endocrine disrupting chemicals can lead to serious diseases from reproductive and neurological disorders to obesity.

13. Increasingly infectious disease will be a result of geologic disturbances such as greater heat, more flooding which will alter the habitat of humans and biological vectors.

14. Ultimately, humans have replaced their relationship with the sun and with plants, to a relationship with fossil fuels and the internal combustion engine. These new relationships are not conducive to health.

Geonotic diseases are a taxonomic reality of ecological medicine which is based on the truism that humans are as healthy (or not) as the surrounding environment.  Unless we change course, the future of human disease is more geonotic chronic diseases.  The future of the Earth is more disruptions of natural systems that will create more human disease and more disease of other living things.